A day in the life of
an online language educator
by Vance Stevens,
Amideast UAE / MLI Project
This
is a prepublication version of an article that appears in the Dec 2002 issue of
the TESL-EJ (Electric Online
Journal). In citations, please use: Stevens, V. 2002. A day in the life of
an online language educator. TESL-EJ 6, 3.
http://www-writing.berkeley.edu/TESL-EJ/ej23/int.html
Yaodong (Meet Yaodong) is an English
teacher in Liuzhou, China. He has very large classes of smiling young students,
as we can see from images broadcast from his web cams. You can imagine that one
of the greatest challenges for an English teacher in the vast interior of China
is arranging for students to have communicative language practice and exposure
to authentic target language through interaction with native speakers of
English. In previous years this would have been out of the question for the
majority of Yaodong’s students. But since Yaodong is willing to experiment
with the Internet, he is able to bring native speakers to his large classes
quite often. This is all the more remarkable when you consider that
Yaodong’s budget supports only the most basic computer equipment and,
fortunately, an Internet connection.
Permission granted by Yaodong
Chen for use of this photo, Dec 17, 2002
How does Yaodong do it? Like many ‘wired’ language teachers
these days, Yaodong has got quite adept at applying to his purposes many of the
CMC (computer-mediated communications) tools available for free on the
Internet. Specifically, he
- keeps current about what tools are available
- experiments with the tools he finds, and
- joins communities of like-minded educators who help him practice with
the tools and keep him informed of latest developments.
The process percolates through cycles of learning more about CMC
technology and experimenting with what is learned, thus being in a position to
learn more, etc. The notion of community is crucial to this process.
Yaodong’s community of teaching colleagues spans the globe. The community
expands as members introduce each other to other colleagues online or gather
either spontaneously or by design in common chat areas (which might even
include f2f or ‘face to face’ meetings at international conferences).
It becomes obvious to anyone wishing to start out with CMC that the
first hurdle is to find a remote partner to experiment with. Once you begin to
interact with a community, partners appear out of the virtual woodwork. Thus
the community serves not only to inform, but also to assist with
experimentation.
Partners are essential to the percolation process. For example, suppose
I install a web cam and want to see if it works. One good way to find out is to
go online and check my buddy lists to find someone else who is online at the
same time I am. I use several programs that tell me when other users of those
programs are online; for example, ICQ,
MSN Messenger, and
Yahoo
Messenger. My buddy lists are full of people I have met over the years whom
I can see online and who can see me online. Chances are there will be someone
online that I can ask if he or she can see my web cam. Most (probably all :-)
people in my virtual community are more than willing to take a few minutes to
help each other with online troubleshooting or items of this nature. If called
upon, I will try to respond, because I might need a similar assist tomorrow,
and more importantly, helping others with what they are trying to do online is
how I gain greater familiarity with the tools and learn how to use them myself.
Yaodong has often asked me to help him surmount this or that
technological hurdle, join him at an interesting Internet site, or take a
moment to speak with his students or with his colleagues before whom he is
using or demonstrating techniques with CMC tools. In one such instance he met
some of our students at the MLI online (using a dialup connection in my office;
Webheads chat logs from December 11,
2001). In another, we engineered a meeting between students in his class
and one in Turkey (Webheads chat logs
from October 29-Nov 3, 2001). That encounter presaged a reunion of the two
classes before a live audience at the Teacher to Teacher 2001 conference in Abu
Dhabi (Webheads chat logs from November
7, 2001), as reported in Stevens and
Altun (2002).
Yaodong is also a great one for trying things out online. Once for
example, he asked me how to broadcast a PowerPoint presentation running on his
computer to mine. I had no idea but together we figured it out, and eventually
I was running the application on his computer from mine, using
Netmeeting. The point
is that, before Yaodong asked me about it from half a world away in Liuzhou
China, I had no idea you could do that with Netmeeting, let alone how, and
after our encounter, we both knew. On another occasion Yaodong contacted me for
help in answering riddles in English. It turned out he was at a MOO called
Grassroots. One
characteristic of MOOs is that they can have 'bots' to interact with real
people who visit the MOO. Yaodong had found a bot at Grassroots that asks
riddles and handles attempts at answering them. Yaodong was doing these with
his students who were getting language practice not only with comprehending and
attempting to answer the riddles, but through interaction with native English
speakers in the 'greater' online environment who were available at the time to
help them understand the riddles and their possible answers. And Yaodong was
making use of the native speakers in his online community to successfully
compensate for his own shortcomings in the language he was teaching, thus
overcoming a common problem often faced by non-native speaker teachers of
foreign languages.
This kind of interaction is fairly typical among community members who
might find each other online and ask for help to test a Netmeeting connection
or troubleshoot a firewall, or even join each other in conference
presentations. Proponents of participation in such communities feel that they
encourage scaffolding among members of the type suggested in the socioculture
theory of Vygotsky (Gallagher,
n.d.), which underpins constructivist (Ryder,
2002) approaches to language learning, such as that embodied in the work of
Bruner (Kearsley, 2002).
More recently there has been increased interest among language educators using
CMC in how these principles mediate the formation and functioning of
communities of practice (Snyder,
n.d.), a construct articulated particularly well by Etienne Wenger (e.g.
Wenger,
1998). Essentially, communities of practice are groups of people who meet
to discuss a topic (technically, a 'domain') of interest to community members.
This topic will be of such interest to CoP members that they will be
intrinsically motivated to enhance their understanding of the topic through
frequent interaction in order to further their work or interest in the field to
which the topic pertains. Obviously, CMC tools can promote the development of
communities of practice over distances.
This brings us to the question of what CMC tools best lend themselves to
distance language practice and formation and cohesion of communities of
practice. Here are some considerations:
- Cost - essentially, these tools must be free (to members of the
community). If they are to appeal to a broad spectrum of users, then they must
be simply 'downloadable' by anyone in the community with an Internet
connection.
- Usability - the tools must easy and intuitive to use. There should be
easy installation, no complicated registration, and intuitive interface
- Multicasting - in order to engage groups of people, the ideal CMC
tools need to broadcast one-to-many. Text easily meets this test, but the
choices for multicasting voice and video (for free!) are limited.
- Cross platform - this is a hard one, but the ideal CMC tools run on
Mac and PC
- Eclecticism - there is no need to look for an all-in-one CMC tool.
Several communications tools can usually be run simultaneously over slow
Internet connections on common denominator computers (although users can
normally have only one sound and one video device running from the same
computer at any given time). Thus CMC enthusiasts can select from a choice of
clients according to need balanced against the foregoing considerations.
And the winner(s) is (are) ...
First, we'll eliminate some otherwise strong contenders for the reasons
indicated below:
No longer free: If we filter down through our 5 considerations,
we find that some tools that have been used recently in language learning and
other CMC contexts are no longer free. Wimba, for example, gave users the ability to
create threaded voice-boards without cost. Now, these voice boards are no
longer freely available (although I have found that you can still send
voice email in demo mode from the Wimba web site). Wimba is a great product and
has working relations with Longman, IBM, and
Blackboard; but users must now purchase
the ability to create threaded voice boards. Another fairly robust voice chat
client is Chatterbox.
Chatterbox allows the creation of voice chat rooms to accommodate numerous
users, but again, it's not free (Chatterbox can be tried out online at
StudyCom English for Internet).
Not easy to use: Most of the free CMC tools that I am aware of
are fairly easy to use (with the possible exception of
iVisit, but we won't reject it on this
count, for reasons you will see in a moment).
Do not support multiple conference users:We can eliminate a few
at this point that (in their freely downloadable form) are strictly one-to-one.
This is the case with MSN Messenger's voice enhanced chat, and Netmeeting
(which wins points on ease of use when conveniently launched from an MSN
Messenger session). Netmeeting is an excellent CMC tool, with a useful
whiteboard in addition to voice and video broadcast. The whiteboard enables
users, for example, to draw or paste an image onto the whiteboard of one
computer and have it appear on the whiteboard of the remote computer (very
handy). Server software to enable Netmeeting multicasting is available but,
unfortunately, not for free.
Allow multicasting: Still standing are three free chat clients
that will enable voice and video multicasts. PalTalk will allow one voice speaker at a
time to communicate in conference with multiple listeners, and these conference
participants can select up to 4 available web cams to view at any one time.
Yahoo Messenger does even better than that, allowing voice users to meet en
masse and speak in duplex in conference mode, with voice quality and users
allowed seemingly limited only by bandwidth available. Yahoo also allows
broadcast and reception of multiple web cams, again limited it seems only by
system resources available to the computer (with Yahoo Messenger, I can easily
get a half dozen web cams and a dozen voice users communicating over a 56k
dialup connection on a PIII laptop, 500 MHz, with 192 meg of RAM, assuming a
robust feed from the dialup). Further good news for Yahoo Messenger is that Mac
users can broadcast and receive video, though it seems that they can't access
Yahoo Messenger voice yet.
Multicasting AND cross-platform: Enter iVisit, a cross-platform
Mac and PC chat client that allows free creation of chat rooms and the ability
to get multiple web cams and voice users therein. However, in practice, and on
the laptop computer mentioned above, I have found the down side to be that the
interface is not intuitive (how do you create a chatroom?), voice can be
erratic or not function at all, and the video display is inferior to Yahoo's.
However, if the community contains both Mac and PC users, and if there is a
need for voice and video enabled chat, iVisit is currently the only choice,
with Yahoo Messenger however becoming increasingly friendly to Mac users.
The best in text chat: We haven't mentioned text chat. All the
above clients are text-enabled, and this is important when sound is not clear,
or when someone wants to copy and paste a URL that the others in the conference
can click on. Most of these I believe will also allow you to save your chats
(though Yahoo Messenger conference chat never saves when I do it, just gives me
a zero byte file, so I have to copy from the chat window and paste to an
application if I want to keep a record, which is supremely inconvenient). But
the best free text chat client, in my opinion, is neither voice nor video
enabled. This is TappedIn, the portal for
a community of educators who can join for free, keep and decorate offices, have
chat transcripts mailed to them, join in online community activities, have
avatars, project URLs on remote computers, and avail themselves of other
features ranging from the amusing to truly utilitarian.
My choices: So down to the final consideration, being eclectic
... the ideal CMC environment available today is an amalgam of all that is
useful above. My own choice for multimedia CMC is to meet in Tapped In and then
open a multiple-user voice chat conference in Yahoo Messenger and share video
windows with those who have web cams. If Mac users are present though, iVisit
might be the best bet, but look for Yahoo to do more in the future to
accommodate Mac users.
Articles referenced
Gallagher, C. (n.d.) Lev Semyonovich Vygotsky (1896 - 1934): Biography,
Theory, Time Line, Bibliography. Retrieved December 24, 2002 from:
http://fates.cns.muskingum.edu/~psych/psycweb/history/vygotsky.htm
Kearsley, G. (2002). Constructivist theory (J. Bruner). Explorations in
Learning & Instruction: The Theory Into Practice Database. Retrieved
December 24, 2002 from: http://tip.psychology.org/bruner.html
Ryder, M. (2002). Constructivism (University of Colorado at Denver,
School of Education. Retrieved December 24, 2002 from:
http://carbon.cudenver.edu/~mryder/itc_data/constructivism.html
Snyder, E. (n.d.). CoPs (Communities of practice). tcm.com inc. Training
and Development Community Center. Retrieved December 24, 2002 from:
http://www.tcm.com/trdev/cops.htm
Stevens, V. and Altun, A. (2002). The Webheads Community of Language
Learners Online. Proceeds from a demonstration given November 7, 2001 at the
MLI Teacher to Teacher Conference, Abu Dhabi, UAE. Retrieved December 23, 2002,
from: http://sites.hsprofessional.com/vstevens/files/efi/papers/t2t2001/proceeds.htm
Wenger, E. (1998) Communities of practice Learning as a social system.
Retrieved December 24, 2002 from:
http://www.co-i-l.com/coil/knowledge-garden/cop/lss.shtml
Web archives cited
Meet Yaodong. Retrieved December 23, 2002, from:
http://sites.hsprofessional.com/vstevens/files/efi/yaodong.htm
Webheads chat logs from October 29-Nov 3, 2001, recording a session
connecting live online in synchronous text, voice, and video-enhanced chat, two
classes of non-native English speakers from Turkey and China - archived here
with pictures from both locations. Retrieved December 23, 2002, from:
http://sites.hsprofessional.com/vstevens/files/efi/chat2001/wfw011031.htm
Webheads chat logs from November 7, 2001, recording transcripts and web
cam shots of a presentation at the MLI Teacher to Teacher Conference. Retrieved
December 23, 2002, from: http://sites.hsprofessional.com/vstevens/files/efi/chat2001/wfw011107.htm
Webheads chat logs from December 11, 2001, recording a meeting of
distance educators with students physically at the MLI. Retrieved December 23,
2002, from: http://sites.hsprofessional.com/vstevens/files/efi/chat2001/wfw011211.htm
Web portals mentioned
StudyCom English for Internet - http://www.study.com
Grassroots - Enabling
Support Foundation - http://www.enabling.org/grassroots/
Tapped
In - SRI International - http://www.tappedin.org
Software mentioned and where to get
it
Blackboard - Blackboard Inc. - http://www.blackboard.com (license
required)
Chatterbox voice chat client - Talking Communities Online -
http://www.talkingcommunities-online.com/Client.html
(license required)
ICQ - ICQ.com - http://web.icq.com (free)
iVisit - iVisit -
http://www.ivisit.com (free)
MSN
Messenger - MSN - http://messenger.msn.com
(free)
Netmeeting - Microsoft -
http://www.microsoft.com/windows/netmeeting/
(free)
Pal Talk - PalTalk.com - http://www.paltalk.com/
Wimba - Wimba -
http://www.wimba.com (license
required)
Yahoo! Messenger - Yahoo! Inc. -
http://messenger.yahoo.com/messenger/download/index.html
|
|
Use the navigation at the top of this
page or your browser's BACK button to return to a previous page
For comments, suggestions, or further information
on this page
contact Vance Stevens, page webmaster.
Last updated: February 3, 2003 in Hot Metal Pro
6.0 |
©opyright 2002 by Vance Stevens
